Animal Aid opposes the export of live animals for slaughter on the grounds that:
- the transportation process is an unnatural and inhumane environment for these animals. It results in extreme distress for all animals and can result in dire welfare outcomes, including disease and death.
- The Australian Government cannot ensure that exported livestock are slaughtered humanely once they have left Australia. There is no guarantee that animals will be treated in line with the Australian community and government standards and expectations.
- the way in which animals are treated cannot be influenced by Australia once they have left Australian shores
- conditions faced by animals during transportation and slaughter is increasingly inconsistent with the expectations and sentiments of the Australian community
The Facts
The following provides an overview of the facts about the live meat export trade:
- Every animal protection organisation in the world opposes live animal export on the basis of unacceptable cruelty.
- Investigations by Animals Australia since 2003 have revealed that despite Australia's involvement in the marketplace for decades, exported animals are still routinely subjected to brutal handling and are slaughtered whilst fully conscious.
- The Australian Government cannot ensure that exported livestock are slaughtered humanely once they have left Australia. Australia allows the supply of animals to countries where there are no laws to protect them from cruelty and where inhumane handling and slaughter are routine. Australian law forbids this type of treatment of animals here and yet the Australian government allows Australian animals to be slaughtered inhumanely overseas.
- Live meat exporters have continued to export animals to countries around the world knowing the inhumane treatment they are subject to in foreign slaughterhouses and knowing these methods are contrary to Australian animal welfare law.
- The live meat export industry supplies the equipment and installations being used to inhumanely slaughter Australian animals overseas
- There is no control over the time Australian animals are in transit. The length of transportation can vary significantly. ‘Trade politics', weather conditions and procedures at the port of unloading can significantly extend the transportation process.
- There is not control over the treatment of Australian animals at disembarkation, the conditions in which they are held in disembarkation facilities, and the way in which they are transferred to slaughterhouses.
- Evidence gathered from importing countries has shown that inhumane slaughter and handling practices, that would be contrary to Australian laws and standards, are common.
Understandings
Animal Aid recognises the significant economic impacts that a change in policy may have in the short-term, both here in Australia and overseas in terms of trade and family livelihood impacts. However, numerous economic reports identify that live exports are undermining Australia's meat processing industry - an industry five times more lucrative than live exports.
To best address these issues Animal Aid encourages all relevant sectors of the community and industry to work together to achieve outcomes that are viable, sustainable and importantly consistent with the values of the Australian community in terms of the humane treatment of Australian animals.
An integrated industry approach to dealing with the issues will create an opportunity for open discussion and will build trust. It will also provide support to those in each sector who want to operate according to Australian laws, standards and community aspirations.
Importantly an integrated industry approach will:
- provide the necessary support to deal with elements within these sectors whose operations and standards are inconsistent with Australian laws, standards and community aspirations,
- formalise strategies for addressing associated issues
- and provide an action plan with associated roles, responsibilities and timelines for implementing the strategies. This will enable the impact of strategies to be formally monitored and reported to the community.
The option
As an alternative to live animal export Animal Aid supports the development of the chilled and frozen meat-only trade. This would mean animals are slaughtered humanely in Australia, processed at Australian facilities and then their meat exported. Ideally these animals will have been farmed through free range and humane farming methods.
References
Animals Australia website and Fact Sheets www.animalsaustralia.org